This blog is a political blog from a left-of-centre perspective. This is not specifically a party political blog, but does have a Lib Dem orientation. Constructive enagement with radical liberals, social democrats / democratic socialists and greens is particularly welcomed.

Thursday, December 15, 2005

Choice

Will the economic Liberals take note of the August findings in a Which? poll as quoted by Simon Jenkins in 'The Guardian' yesterday :

"...90% of people did not want choice,just a good hospital within easy reach".

The same is true of schools and most public services. Where is the evidence to the contrary.

2 Comments:

Blogger Stephen Tall said...

Of course everyone wants a good school, hospital etc within easy reach. I do, you do, we all do. The tougher question is: how do you achieve that?

As an economic liberal, I'm in favour of markets because they (i) introduce competition, which I think drives up standards; and (ii) allow us to prioritise scarce resources.

I dislike monopolies - whether private or state-run - because it restricts our freedom of choice.

Take the example of a council house... On one level, a tenant only wants a good, solid door. But they might also like to be given a choice of which colour it should be.

12:40 pm GMT

 
Blogger Liberal Neil said...

As an economic liberal, I'm in favour of markets because they (i) introduce competition, which I think drives up standards; and (ii) allow us to prioritise scarce resources.

So if the evidence was that competition in a particular public service achieved neither of these two things you would be happy not to see it then?

Take the example of a council house... On one level, a tenant only wants a good, solid door. But they might also like to be given a choice of which colour it should be.

This isn't a very good example ... (1) they have choice of whether to rent from the council or not and, (2)it is quite possible for a council to give tenants a choice of door colour and many other things besides.

9:17 pm GMT

 

Post a Comment

<< Home